Showing posts with label math. Show all posts
Showing posts with label math. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 28, 2023

Repeat to Understand: Improving Math Discussions through Repetition

When students share their mathematical thinking in a group, it's important that everyone's voice feels heard. One effective technique to ensure this is to have another student repeat the thinking of the person who shared. This strategy, which we saw in many Developing Mathematical Ideas (DMI) videos (as part of the Master of Arts in Teaching Mathematics at Mt Holyoke College), was also recommended by my colleague Louisa for my Student Thinking Assignments in the 2021-22 school year.

There are several benefits to using this approach. First, it amplifies the voice of the student who originally shared their thinking and communicates to the class that their ideas are valued. Second, when a student's thinking is repeated, more students have a chance to hear and understand it. In a busy and distracting classroom, hearing ideas twice can help students pay closer attention. Third, repeating the thinking provides an opportunity to check for understanding. If the repetition is incorrect, we can quickly identify any misunderstandings or communication issues.

Echoing student voices by having another student repeat their thinking is a simple and effective technique to use in your elementary math classroom. It promotes inclusion, helps clarify ideas, and encourages active listening among students.

In your next math class, give it a shot and see how it goes. Then leave me a comment and let me know how it worked for you!

Questions to Reflect & Refine
  • In what ways could echoing student voices benefit my classroom math discussions? How could it support student learning?
  • How might I use or adapt this technique to suit the needs of my classroom and my students? How might I regularly incorporate this strategy into my practice?
  • Can I think of any other strategies to ensure that all my students' voices are heard in math discussions?
Ideas that came up based on feedback from others:
  • When students are hesitant or afraid to vocalize their ideas/processes, being the "repeater" is actually much lower stakes. They can still be a part of the conversation, but they don't have to vulnerably share their own ideas if they aren't ready to, yet. (Larry)
  • This technique is described above in the context of a small or large group, but could also be a strategy students would use in pairs as a way to show their partner was actively listening. The way the technique is used is dependent on the purpose. (Melissa)
  • What happens if the math thinking originally shared is incorrect? Do you still have that thinking echoed? (Melissa)
  • Repetition is a super important technique. Students teaching, after gaining expertise, can really boost the repetitions. Giving students multiple modeling opportunities advantages all. (Amy)
  • This community has potential to build community. (Judi)
  • An important precursor to using a technique like this is to lay out norms and expectations for the group. It is also important students know the purpose; to amplify voices, promote inclusion and clarify ideas. This "echoing" technique shouldn't be looked on as a listening quiz, but rather a chance to restate and reframe. (Louisa)
  • When students get used to listening to other students' math thinking and sharing their own thinking, the ownership for learning, thinking and teaching shifts towards the students, giving them agency. (Jennifer) 
  • This strategy would be useful in other areas as well, not just in the mathematics classroom (Ashley)

Friday, January 29, 2016

5 steps to teach concepts ... in math

Last year, I shared a blog post with friends and colleagues on Facebook entitled "Are You Doing It Wrong? How to Introduce Telling Time" by Cindy Lee of Ainslee Labs (which has since been reposted here: Avoid the biggest mistake teachers make when teaching time ).

It caught the attention of my second grade colleagues and now together, we're trying to figure out how to put Ms. Lee's ideas into practice with students.

Traditionally, students are introduced to telling time by first learning time to the hour. Next, students learn to tell time to the half hour, then to the quarter hour, then to the nearest five minutes and finally to the exact minute.

Ms. Lee has experience that shows this way is confusing to kids (I've had that same experience!). We first teach kids to look wherever the short hand is pointing to to read the hour. But soon thereafter, this understanding becomes a misconception.

To address this confusion, Ms. Lee suggests using a clock graphic colorfully divided into twelfths, teaching the kids that each hour has an area or space that belongs to them.

Below, I've detailed how I used my five-step concept-based lesson framework to introduce this idea to the students.

1. Start with a concept
.

Before the lesson, I decided on three related objectives to make sure that my lesson was three-dimensional (to learn more about 3D curriculum and instruction see anything by Lynn Erickson).

Concept: The students will understand that you can't achieve your goal if you use the right tool the wrong way.

Knowledge: The students will know that the hour has an area or space that belongs to them on the clock.

Skill: The students will be able to read the hour on a clock, regardless of how many minutes have passed.

Although I was specifically concerned with students gaining mathematical knowledge and skill during this lesson, I was equally interested in them learning the timeless, abstract, universal and transferable idea that even if you're using the right tool, you need to use it the right away to be able to reach your goals. Striking a balance between teaching and learning knowledge, skill and concept objectives is paramount, in concept-based teaching.

2. Pick a specific, concrete example of a person, place, situation, or thing that illustrates that concept & 3. Create an opportunity for students to explore that concrete example.

To introduce students to the concept of using the right tool the right way, I brought in a tool box, a hammer, a small board and my lanyard.


I told them I had a goal of making a lanyard hanger so that it wouldn't get tangled on my shelf at home. We first chatted about the right tool I'd need out of my toolbox. When we decided that a hammer was indeed the right tool, I tried to hammer in the nail with the end of the hammer. When that didn't work, a student suggested I use the top of the hammer. When that didn't work, someone suggested I used the circle part of the top.

As the nail went into the board, so too did the idea into the kids' brains that you need the right tool used the right way to get the job done!

Then I introduced them to another tool - a clock.

"When we use a clock as our tool, what is our goal?" I asked.

As one girl offered (and all the second graders agreed), we use clocks to read the time.

So, I asked the students to write on their whiteboards what the time was on each of the following clocks:




All the students were able to accurately tell me the time. We all agreed that to read the time on those clocks, you just needed to look where the hour-hand was pointing.

"Okay," I said, "now tell me what time it is."



We counted together that 55 minutes had passed and they all had to read the hour by themselves. Just like clockwork (pun completely intended) all but 1 or 2 students said it was 2:55.


Then, we had a conversation about how we had been using the right tool to tell the time, but we were using it in the wrong way.

Next, I showed them the clock face with the partitioned hours (thanks again to Ainslee Labs for the free clock face. Want to pay for her whole telling time kit?).


We used this clock face to practice telling the time with various times. Over and over again, the students had no trouble identifying the correct hour, even when the hour hand wasn't pointing directly to a particular number. Eventually I removed the gray numbers inside the clock and 100% of the students were
able to read the hour on a clock, regardless of how many minutes have passed because they knew that the hour has an area or space that belongs to them on the clock.

4. Check for understanding by having them write a concept statement. 

(This step is very similar to the thinking routine Headlines found in Making Thinking Visible by Ritchhart, Church, and Morrison, p. 111)

Since I was confident that the students had reached the knowledge and skill objectives of the lesson, I asked, "What did you learn today about how you should use a tool to achieve your goal?".


I gave the students a chance to write down their individual responses on their whiteboards and then one-by-one we shared until everyone's ideas were represented in our statement. Below is the sequence of revisions that our conceptual statement when through. My prompts are highlighted in yellow.

"What do you have to remember about tools when trying to achieve a goal?" First child responds:


"Does anyone want to add anything?" Second child adds:




"Does anyone want to add anything?" Third child adds:



 "Is this true just when we're telling time?" Fourth child adds:



"Who needs to do all of this?" Fifth child responds:



"That doesn't sound right." Sixth child corrects: 



The students were comfortable that their conceptual statement encapsulated all the learning they had done up until that point, so we ended the lesson there.


Often times when crafting conceptual statements (sometimes called generalizations, central ideas, or enduring understandings) we create hard-to-understand statements that don't sound like how we normally talk. Concept statements should be written in language that is easy to understand to all who read it. One way to do this is let the students craft the statement, as we did together in this lesson.

5. Reflect on their thinking and decide next steps.

Moving forward, I would want these students to continue to practice reading the hour using this partitioned clock. Eventually, I would want them to independently be able to read the hours and the minutes first with the partitions and then after slowly taking away that support.

Conceptually, I would want to explore other tools and discuss the correct way to use them and contrast that with the wrong way to use them. This conversation would fit in wonderfully with any beginning-of-the-year guided discoveries that students experience as they are exploring the learning tools of the classroom.

After reading how I used a clock lesson to teach a timeless, abstract, universal and transferable concept to second graders, how do you teach these BIG IDEAS to your students?

Monday, January 11, 2016

Teaching 21st Century Skills with Minecraft

In an attempt to help students who struggle in the areas of literacy and math, our school hosts Learning Academy, a before-school academic support class where students are able to practice and refine skills taught during the school day.

Students are invited to attend Learning Academy when they show they have a deficit in literacy and/or math skills, but it important to remember that these students - nay, all students - also require time and opportunities to develop thinking and communication skills, some of which have collectively become known as 21st Century Skills or the 4Cs: communication, collaboration, critical thinking and creativity.

http://fargopublicschools.areavoices.com/files/2014/09/21st-Century-Skills-4-Cs-graphic.jpg
To foster and support the development of these 21st Century Skills, I invited some of the Learning Academy participants to take part in a @MinecraftEdu class after being introduced to MinecraftEdu at a workshop presented by Alan November (@globalearner). MinecraftEdu is a "school-ready remix of the original smash hit game Minecraft." It builds on the excitement and engagement generated by the game-version of Minecraft to give students an environment in which they can develop and refine various academic and social skills.

Students worked together in worlds downloaded from the MinecraftEdu World Library that other users had created. We worked in the following worlds: Tutorial World, Multiplying Decimal Numbers, and The Island. In these challenging worlds, students worked on mathematical skills such as understanding coordinate systems, multiplying decimals and long division while exploring, hunting and navigating through adventurous worlds full of obstacles and pitfalls.

After working for several weeks in those worlds, I created a (very simple) world of my own, where I gave students tasks that would allow them to continue to practice mathematical concepts while also giving them the chance to create and build. Below, is a short video showing the students' work on one particular mathematical task I had set up in this world.


Now that this first group of kids has been with me for several months, it is time for the students to move on and a new group to start learning with MinecraftEdu. The week before I said goodbye to this first group of students, I asked them if they could write up a reflection of what they learned, how they learned it and why they learned it. Below are their reflections. 






After reading about how I used MinecraftEdu to help students develop skills of communication, creativity, and creative & critical problem-solving how do you help your students develop these skills in your classroom?

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

Teaching Math in Authentic Contexts

Our staff recently has been examining the question: "What does math teaching and learning look like in a Primary Years Program (PYP)?"

To answer this question, we explored the text "Mathematics in the Primary Years Programme," one of the subject annexes from Making the PYP happen: A curriculum framework for international primary education. In that document, teachers were able to see the clear vision of how math teaching and learning should look like in our PYP.


To document their thinking, teachers created a Practice Profile (a rubric of teacher behavior) based on what they were reading in the text. As primary and intermediate teachers were working in separate sessions, there were two separate practice profiles created and can be found here: KEC PYP Math Practice Profile - Primary and Intermediate.


An important idea that came up during that professional learning engagement was that in a PYP classroom, teachers should provide students with multiple opportunities to explore relevant problems both inside and out of the units of inquiry. The math annex provides some guidance on concepts that might be best suited for learning in context when they say, "data handling, measurement, and shape and space are best studied in authentic contexts provided by the transdisciplinary units of inquiry," because they represent the "areas of mathematics that other disciplines use to research, describe, represent, and understand aspects of their domain," (p. 85 of Making the PYP Happen).


Reflecting on this new understanding of math instruction in the PYP, one G2 teacher planned for her students to create a timeline, an authentic opportunity to explore the abstract mathematical concepts of measurement, subtraction, space, and time. She knew that the timeline would give her students a better understanding of the heroes they were studying in their unit of inquiry, as they were trying to make sense of the big idea that people influence the world in different ways.


First, the students created the timeline using the scale 1 cm = 1 year. The students worked together to create century strips, each measuring a meter (and alternating in color).


Then, the students needed to figure out how long each of the heroes' strips should be. The teacher modeled how to use a number line to figure out the age of the hero they'd be researching. Using the birth date and death date (or the current date for living heroes), the students figured the difference between the two. It is important to mention that the students did pretty well with this since they have been using number lines and open number lines all year for almost every math topic. This shows how effective it is to give students the opportunity to use the same thinking tools and structures over and over again until they become routine.

Next, students used that information to create strips for each of their heroes, again with the scale 1 cm = 1 year.




Finally, the teacher gave students the opportunity to look at the timeline and document their observations, thoughts, and questions using the thinking routine See-Think-Wonder (from Making Thinking Visible by Ritchhart, Morrison, & Church).


This G2 teacher continues to see other ways that math can be learned in meaningful ways during her unit of inquiry. Recently, she used the data they had collected on heroes' ages to introduce median, mode and range. Using the data the students had already collected made it more authentic and engaging.


The students found that their heroes ranged in age from 37 to 95, a range of 58 years. Kids were surprised and impressed because that seemed like a lot. There were two medians and two modes, so that was confusing for their introduction to the idea of analyzing a data set using those tools, but it was engaging nonetheless.

After reading about how this G2 teacher taught the mathematical concepts of measurement, difference, and data in the authentic context of her unit of inquiry, how could you or have you taught math in meaningful, engaging and authentic ways?

Saturday, February 7, 2015

Making Professional Thinking Visible


Effective professional learning is engaging, relevant, connected to long-term goals, and involves participants in interactively constructing understanding. Because thinking routines (especially like those described in Making Thinking Visible by Ritchhart, Church, and Morrison) are tools, structures, and patterns of behavior that are used to initiate, explore, discuss, document, and manage thinking, they can be used by educators during professional development to help actively become engaged in constructing understanding. Furthermore, since they're experienced themselves, those educators are more likely to use those thinking routines with their students, a vital part of creating a culture of thinking in their own classrooms.

Therefore, at a recent pedagogical leadership team meeting, when one of the leaders 
asked other teams how they guided their students through solving mathematical word problems, I knew that using a thinking routine would help guide us through that exploration.

Here is that story:

Start with a concept.

We started with the timeless, abstract, universal, and transferable idea that solving problems independently is made easier by following a set protocol.

Pick a specific, concrete example of a person, place, situation, or thing that illustrates that concept.

In order to gain an understanding of that abstract idea, we explored different protocols used by teachers throughout our building to help their students solve mathematical problems independently.

Create an opportunity for participants to explore that concrete example.

During this phase of the conversation, we agreed to dialogue and suspend judgement. For more information about dialogue, discussion, and how both can be used to transform conversations we have in schools into meaningful communication, see "Teacher Talk That Makes a Difference" by Robert Garmston and Bruce Wellman.

To guide our dialogue, we followed the thinking routine See-Think-Wonder from Making Thinking Visible by Ritchhart, Church, and Morrison (p. 55).

See: What do we see?

During this phase of the dialogue, team members shared the protocols they use with their students to solve mathematical word problems. Comments and crosstalk were discouraged.


1st protocol shared:
  1. What are you trying to find?
  2. What numbers will you use?
  3. Open number sentence - using a variable for the unknown
  4. Decide what to do with a remainder
2nd protocol shared: (students don’t have to follow these in order)
  1. Make a prediction
  2. Answer
  3. Number sentence
  4. Strategy
  5. Show your thinking
3rd protocol shared: U.P.S. Check
  1. Understand: look at the problem and understand what it is asking us to do. What are we trying to find out?
  2. Plan: What do we need in the number story to solve the problem? Circle the important points.
  3. Solve, using different strategies.
  4. Check: Solve it a different way, using another strategy to see if you get the same result.
4th protocol shared: (for behavior problem-solving)
  1. What are you doing that I can’t allow?
  2. Why can’t I allow you to do that?
  3. What will you do instead, next time? 
5th protocol shared: ORID
  1. Objective: What do we know about this?
  2. Reflective: How do we feel about this?
  3. Interpretive: What does this mean for us?
  4. Decisional: What are we going to do? 
6th protocol shared: For solving 2-step word problems
  1. Equation
  2. Representation (including acting it out), to check for understanding
  3. 1st step
  4. Next step
  5. Answer with a label 
7th protocol shared:
  1. What do you want to find out?
  2. What do you know?
  3. What will you do? 
8th protocol shared: Cognitively Guided Instruction (CGI)
  1. Read the problem.
  2. What do I know?
  3. What is the question?
  4. What strategy will I use?
  5. Organize my thinking so others can understand what I did.
  6. Answer the question in a complete thought. 
9th protocol shared: from George Pólya's four key principles to "problem solving" first published the book “How to Solve It” (1945):
  1. Understand the problem
  2. Devise a plan
  3. Carry out the plan
  4. Look back
Think: What do we think?

Next, leaders were invited to comment on what they had just heard, noting any "big ideas" that surfaced during the sharing period.
  • There is more than one way to solve problems.
  • There are a lot of similarities, but in different language.
  • Protocols range from a lot of steps to a few steps.
  • Lots of visual aids, graphic organizers 
  • Acting out and using manipulatives helps.
Wonder: What does this make us wonder?
  • Do we all have to be doing the same thing?
  • Would this be a site-based decision or district-wide?
  • Using the various protocols, what’s the level of independent use?
  • Can students name the strategy they’re using?
  • Do the protocols we’re using lead to innate problem-solving (are students internalizing the steps)?
  • Can kids explain why they’re using a particular strategy?
  • Does the district math coordinator have any insight?
  • What do math experts have to say?
  • What language constructs need to be supported?
  • How much of this is a vocabulary issue and not a math issue?
  • Could the vocab piece be consistent throughout the grades?
  • Does our curriculum use the same language as the standardized tests that our students take?
  • Should protocols be teacher-given or student-created?
  • If protocols are student-created, how can teachers support students? Is this the right way to go?
  • Can we use prompts like “show me your thinking” and “did anyone solve this in a different way?” along with these protocols?
Check for understanding by having them write a concept statement.
After our discussion, leaders were asked to respond to this question: "What can you tell me about how we can make solving problems independently easier for our students?"































Reflect on their thinking and decide next steps.
After analyzing and reflecting on the responses above, here are the big ideas I see surfacing. What do you see?

A protocol for solving problems in math should:

  • require students to make their thinking visible (or verbal).
  • require students to show different strategies to solve the problem.
  • help students identify vocabulary that is essential to understand the problem.
  • help students visualize the problem.
  • have few steps so students can use it independently.
  • be universal so it can be used at all ability levels.
  • be transferable to all settings where problems need to be solved.
  • be student-created (at least partially).
  • help students develop PYP attitudes like creativity, commitment (persistence/grit), independence.

Sunday, November 2, 2014

Making Mathematical Thinking Visible with The Explanation Game

In Minnesota, third graders need to be able to represent multiplication facts by using a variety of approaches, such as repeated addition, equal-sized groups, arrays, area models, equal jumps on a number line and skip counting (3.1.2.3).

For students aged 8- and 9-years-old, this mathematics benchmark is quite dense. Even the "I Can" statement, written in kid-friendly language, is still fairly complex and abstract.




To help her students understand the concept and be able to successfully demonstrate the skill described in this benchmark, one third grade teacher used the Thinking Routine The Explanation Game (from Making Thinking Visible by Ritchhart, Morrison, and Church.)

This teacher wanted her students to look closely at features and details of the different ways to show multiplication facts, so The Explanation Game seemed like the perfect thinking routine to elicit that type of thinking from her students.


During the Explanation Game, students take a close look at something they're trying to understand and:


Name it. Name a feature that you notice.

Explain it. What could it be? What role or function might it serve? Why might it be there?
Give reasons. What makes you say that? Or why do you think it happened that way?
Generate alternatives. What else could it be? And what makes you say that?

With her students, the teacher made six posters, each with a different way to represent multiplication facts. The teacher purposefully left off the name of the particular multiplication strategy shown on the poster.

The students then had to answer these questions:

  • What is the multiplication equation shown? 
  • What strategy are you using to show that equation? Explain the strategy to a partner. 
  • Write another equation and solve it using that strategy. 
Finally, the students labeled each poster with the name of the particular multiplication strategy. By allowing the students to independently construct their own understanding of the multiplication strategy first and then naming each strategy, the teacher was guiding her students' learning with inquiry, a powerful vehicle for learning in the IB Primary Years Program.

Below are the posters after the learning engagement.













Teachers in other grade levels could use this same Thinking Routine and lesson structure to address mathematics benchmarks at their particular grade level, particularly when the benchmark requires students to represent a number or a mathematical operation in a variety of ways. The list of benchmarks below is not an exhaustive list, but is only provided to show the variety of settings in which this Thinking Routine and lesson structure could be used.

Kindergarten (K.1.1.2): Read, write, and represent whole numbers from 0 to at least 31. Representations may include numerals, pictures, real objects and picture graphs, spoken words, and manipulatives such as connecting cubes. 

1st grade (1.1.2.1): Use words, pictures, objects, length-based models (connecting cubes), numerals and number lines to model and solve addition and subtraction problems in part-part-total, adding to, taking away from and comparing situations.

2nd grade (2.1.2.1):Use strategies to generate addition and subtraction facts including making tens, fact families, doubles plus or minus one, counting on, counting back, and the 
commutative and associative properties.

4th grade (4.1.2.1): Represent equivalent fractions using fraction models such as parts of a set, fraction circles, fraction strips, number lines and other manipulatives. 

5th grade (5.1.1.1):  Recognize that quotients can be represented in a variety of ways, including a whole number with a remainder, a fraction or mixed number, or a decimal. 

6th grade (6.1.1.4): Determine equivalences among fractions, decimals and percents; select among these representations to solve problems. 

Wednesday, September 3, 2014

Zoom In

A fifth grade teacher recently used the visible thinking routine Zoom In (from Making Thinking Visible by Ritchhart, Church, and Morrison) with her students to help them describe, infer and interpret multiplication arrays.

Read about the experience in the teacher's own words:

Beforehand, I created a simple picture array of identical plants, 3 rows by 6 columns, 18 total plants.

To start off, I told the students that we would start digging into our first math unit and we would be using the visible thinking routine Zoom In to help us do that. I explained that we’d start by looking at a small part of a picture and we’d reveal a little bit more each time. Their job was to observe and jot down what they noticed on their whiteboards.

First, I showed them just one plant.


The students focused on observations of what was in the picture - describing the plant.


Between each round, students shared out their observations and I recorded them on the SMART board. By having students share their thinking, it allowed their classmates to hear what others were thinking and noticing. This helped in making their own observations as they added on to what other students had shared. It also allowed me to ask students to tell more and explain what their thinking meant or how they came up with their predictions.


The next zoom moved across the row to show one more plant, doubling the plants but not yet revealing a full row or column. I asked them to again observe: "What did they see? What new things did they notice? How did their thinking change based on the new parts of the picture they were seeing?"


There were still many plant-based observations and a few mathematical words started to pop out (doubling, multiplying).




Again, I recorded their thinking on the board, as students shared their thinking.



Round 3 revealed two full columns. I reminded students at the beginning of this round that we were looking at the picture as mathematicians and asked them to think about their observations with a math mindset.


Again they wrote down observations, noting how their thinking had changed and how they might think about the picture mathematically. During this round, students independently began predicting what they thought might come next in the picture without any prompting from me.





A synthesis of the class's thinking:



Round 4 revealed a full row, in addition to the 2 full columns they had seen in the previous round. 



During this round of observations, students had discovered the pattern of rows and columns, and most observations focused on predictions of how many plants were going to be in the full picture. Some students were observing using row-and-column strategies, while others were using multiples of 3 or 6.



Everyone's thinking together:




In the last round, the full array was displayed.



By this point, all students could name it as an array and write the corresponding number sentence.



Everyone's thinking after the last Zoom In round:




To wrap up, I asked students to draw another array for 18. All students were able to create another array, which showed me they all understood the concept of a rectangular array and equal rows and columns.



After reading about how this 5th grade teacher used the visible thinking routine Zoom In to help her students describe, infer, and interpret in math, how could you use a visible thinking routine to help your students think deeply about mathematical concepts?